It’s been a long time coming, but reform to the National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP) is on the way. It looks like the government is following the lead of private flood insurers and making some changes to the way they rate flood policies. That’s a good thing. The existing NFIP is broken and broke. It consistently pays out more for losses than it takes in as premiums. The Congressional Budget Office nerds estimate that the program will rack up losses of $1.4 billion each year under the current program.
FEMA Risk Rating 2.0 (that’s how we Flood Nerd-types refer to the reform) isn’t a complete re-boot but it’s going to change the flood insurance market. How the change affects homeowners, business owners, and condo associations will vary depending on your property location and your flood policy.
Here’s just an overview of the changes. In future blogs, I’ll give you a Nerd’s eye view, so you are better prepared for any potential changes to your policy and coverage.
There are major changes and small changes coming with Risk Rating 2.0. Here’s a rundown on what I think are the most important changes.
A Tisket a Tasket – Every House Goes in a Basket
One of the biggest changes to the NFIP Risk Rating 2.0 will be how they rate policies. For too many years they overcharged half of their customers (hostages?) and undercharged the other half. It seemed as if no one really paid the right amount. FEMA 2.0 changes the policy rating framework.
Instead of relying solely on maps and elevation certificates, the new methodology places homes in market “baskets”. The baskets will contain single-family homes with similar property and policy coverage characteristics for that region. Rating will begin to resemble how risk is assessed for other types of insurance. They call it “equity,” I think it’s just common sense – something that’s not always common in Washington D.C.
FEMA Discovers Technology
For years now, the private flood insurance market has used high-tech to better understand the risk of flooding. They used uber-smart computers, algorithms, and satellite images to rate policies while FEMA stuck to maps and a dusty abacus. Well, okay – not really – the abacus was dusted regularly. But FEMA didn’t take advantage of the latest technology. That’s about to change.
FEMA isn’t throwing away their flood maps, but they are adding additional flood risk variables, and private sector data, and incorporating new actuarial science and catastrophe models. So things like your foundation type, prior claims, and distance to a flood source will now be considered. So will urban flooding. I think the days of two identical homes side-by-side paying wildly different rates are over. At least we can hope.
Homeowners in Washington, Oregon, California, Alaska, and Hawaii pay attention! FEMA 2.0 will factor in the risk of a tsunami into the new coastal rates. However, FEMA 2.0 will exclude tsunami risk from the rates for property that is 20 miles inland from the Pacific Ocean or in California ZIP codes 92647, 92648, and 92649. FEMA 2.0 excludes tsunami risk in the Atlantic Ocean – they say they couldn’t find a reliable model. Maybe that’s because the most significant tsunami in the Atlantic basin was in 1755 and affected Lisbon, Portugal. The NFIP doesn’t insure other countries like Portugal.
Great Walls O’ Water
The coastal parts of the Great Lakes are not at risk of tsunami, but they can be impacted by seiche flooding. This is a standing wall of water or a huge wave that is caused by strong winds and a rapid change in atmospheric pressure.
Previously, VE zones in the Great Lakes area did not account for seiche flooding. Under FEMA 2.0, the basket for these properties will include the risk of seiche flooding.
Replacement Cost Value
One of the great advantages of private insurance is the ability to insure for the replacement cost. Under the existing NFIP, the first $60,000 of building coverage and $25,000 in contents coverage is rated at a higher amount and the remaining coverage is rated at a lower amount. There is no consideration given to the actual cost to replace the building or the contents and the coverage is capped at $250,000. Oh, the times they are a-changing!
FEMA 2.0 will use a replacement cost value to calculate premiums, but they will still limit you to $250,000 in coverage. But the rate is the rate, and the two-tier system is going away. If your existing coverage is over $60,000 then you won’t be getting the cut you previously enjoyed. But if the cost to rebuild your home is over $250,000, you’ll still need to get excess coverage. Some things never change.
Giving Credit Where Credit is Due
Flood mitigation efforts are rewarded in FEMA 2.0. Elevating the building on posts, piles, or piers can save you money. Move the building machinery and equipment up off the lowest floor and you’ll get a break too. Flood openings and windows, when done in accordance with FEMA rules will still give you a break but they must be certified by FEMA to earn mitigation credits.
Special Hazard Discounts
FEMA isn’t throwing those flood maps in the trash or burning them in a bonfire. They will still use them to determine Special Flood Hazard zones.
But the good news is that Special Flood Hazard Community Rating System discounts now apply to all policies in the area not just the ones in the special hazard area. The discount will be applied as a flat percentage across the entire community. Oh, the benefits of those property baskets! This could cause your current premium to go down.
Prior Claim Penalties
FEMA 2.0 is going to wipe the slate clean. Just as if a flood had swept in and washed away all claim history. Well, once again I exaggerate just a bit.
But under FEMA 2.0 the surcharge incurred for a claim within the last 20 years only applies to claims filed after FEMA 2.0 goes into effect. That’s October 1, 2021, for some folks. But, and this is really important, once a claim is filed, the penalty for prior claims is calculated on a rolling 20-year basis. So if you buy a home that has prior claims, when you first buy the insurance, you won’t pay a penalty. But, if you ever file a claim, you’ll be assessed a penalty for all the prior claims – even if you didn’t own the property.
In a Nutshell
Under FEMA 2.0, flood policies will not be rated on a flood zone map. They will be rated on: